Vulnerable Individuals Residing in Unsafe Homes Amid Delays in Law Enforcement

Vulnerable people with care needs are residing in “beyond disgraceful” homes, according to claims by Members of Parliament and charities, due to the government’s failure thus far to enforce a new law. The Supported Housing Act was enacted in June last year with the aim of establishing standards within the sector. This followed a select committee’s finding that a lack of regulation enabled some landlords to “profit” from “unacceptably poor housing.” However, there has been no consultation regarding its implementation, and an advisory panel for the sector has not yet been formed. The government attributed these delays to the election, affirming its commitment to both the consultation and the panel. Rhys Matthews, 26, informed the BBC that one particular scheme was “the worst place I’ve ever lived.” Local councils determine whether individuals with care needs, such as mental or physical health conditions, qualify for supported housing. They also identify providers and manage rent payments. While many charities and other non-profit organizations provide supported housing without issues, the housing select committee discovered problems arose over the last decade when private firms began entering the sector to offer “exempt” supported accommodation. This arrangement allows tenants to use their benefits for rent, a practice from which they are typically exempt. Charities and MPs contend that these exempt supported housing companies have exploited insufficient regulation and the benefit loophole to accrue millions while providing low-quality housing. In response to these concerns, the new legislation empowers the department for housing and local councils to establish standards for supported housing providers. Nevertheless, a precise start date for a consultation on how the law will function has not been determined. A housing spokesperson stated that a “clear commitment…to consulting on further measures early next year” had been made. Concurrently, the supported housing advisory panel, intended to consist of sector representatives who would inform the government, has also not been established. The law stipulated its formation by June. The government declared its “commitment to establishing” the panel. Rhys, having been raised in foster care, transitioned into supported housing because of health issues. He recounted to the BBC that his room’s sole furnishings were a bed and a small cabinet, leading him to pile his possessions on the floor. He reported being evicted with only an hour’s notice after another resident threw a knife at him, resulting in him spending the subsequent two years living on the streets. “It almost felt like I was the issue, I was the problem, and they wanted to get rid of me,” he said. He added, “I had no idea what my rights were.” Rhys currently resides in supported housing supplied by the charity Emmaus, where he receives payment for his work. Rhys, aligning with the charities interviewed, advocates for the new supported housing law to enforce minimum standards, including larger rooms, secure shared spaces, and qualified support staff. He desires that landlords failing to meet these standards face criminal convictions in the most severe instances. “It needs to have bite,” he stated. Jasmine Basran, head of policy and campaigns at the homeless charity Crisis, remarked: “People who have already experienced significant disadvantage are being forced to live without adequate support in unsafe, unsanitary and frankly unliveable conditions.” She noted that the government’s intention to consult on improving supported housing was promising, “but we do need to see progress on this – urgently.” Charlotte Talbott, chief executive of Emmaus UK, commented that there were “far too many cases where individuals are let down by unscrupulous providers, with substandard support and accommodation having devastating consequences for those who depend on their services.” The London Assembly characterized the sector as “unsafe and unregulated.” Furthermore, a 2022 BBC investigation uncovered that exempt supported housing schemes across the West Midlands were rife with crime, drugs, and, in one instance, a death. Despite years of apprehension, action has been slow, a situation that does not surprise Rhys. “It’s so typical from the government,” he remarked. “Unfortunately, with supported accommodation and homelessness, it always seems to take a back [seat] in any government, Labour or Conservative,” he added. Bob Blackman MP, who authored the Act, criticized the “snail’s pace” of its enforcement, stressing the urgent need for action as the sector represents a “ticking time bomb.” The housing department affirmed that “it was right that decisions on the consultation were paused during the general election.” They further indicated that panel members “will be appointed in due course” after interviews concluded this month. The National Housing Federation (NHF) stated that even if the law is enforced, it would not resolve “extreme financial challenges caused by severe cuts to funding, combined with rocketing inflation and increasing operating costs.” It estimates that over a third of supported housing providers closed schemes last year, and 60% intend to close sites in the future. While the supply of supported housing is decreasing, many charities report that demand has surged due to NHS cuts and rising homelessness. Sophie Boobis, head of policy and research at Homeless Link, emphasized the necessity of the consultation so that effective providers could establish a benchmark for quality and mitigate the uncertainty created by the absence of regulation. “This is a sector at risk…It feels like a pressure cooker at the moment,” she concluded. Copyright 2024 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC holds no responsibility for the content of external websites. Information regarding our approach to external linking is available.