Reader Opinions on Officiating Following St Mirren’s Defeat at Tannadice

Following St Mirren’s loss to Dundee United, the publication invited readers to share their perspectives. Below are some of the responses received: Jim commented: “If you can’t challenge for the ball in your own box, and it was a 50/50 challenge, then football as we remember it has gone. Two very dubious decisions have spoiled a very even game. Both sides lacked the killer blow and a well deserved draw would have been just about right. A lack of striking power must be a concern for the Saints staff.” Douglas stated: “Well… was at Tannadice and I thought I had seen bad refereeing before but that has to be the lowest of the low and in the VAR studio just as bad. Jack Walton had to be sent off and the penalties awarded were not penalty kicks. Marcus Fraser’s red card, never. Wasn’t even a booking.” Ian remarked: “Frankly, very poor officiating and not a good advert for VAR. TV evidence confirms this opinion. A goalkeeper who should have been sent off and two very dubious penalties. St Mirren could be careless at times but deserved something from the game. The scoreline flattered United.”