Women Voters Discuss Abortion’s Influence on Their Choices in the 2024 Election

The 2024 presidential election marks the initial election following the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v Wade, a ruling that had previously safeguarded the nationwide right to abortion. A notable gender gap has emerged in this election, with surveys indicating Kamala Harris holds an edge among female voters, while former President Donald Trump maintains a comparable lead among male voters. The BBC has engaged with women voters to understand their perspectives on gender and abortion as they prepare to cast their votes in the concluding phase of the campaign. Michelle, a 38-year-old quality engineer residing in Arizona and a registered Republican, intends to vote for Kamala Harris. “I’m concerned about women’s rights and women’s health care. I’m not a one-issue voter, but that is a huge one. I work in the medical sector and I was very personally affected by the overturn of Roe v Wade because I wasn’t able to get access to a lot of the drugs I needed. Nobody was sure of what the legality was… even though they’re used for other things. The whole Republican stance is smaller government and don’t let government make my personal decisions, so why are they trying to legislate what a woman can do with her body? [A Harris presidency] would mean that all the things that my parents told me when I was younger were true – that just because you’re a girl doesn’t mean that you are limited.” A nurse practitioner from Texas, who supported Trump in the previous presidential election, plans to vote for him once more. “[Trump] has definitely said things that he probably should have unsaid. I would have to shake my finger at that, especially as a woman, but I have yet to hear anything that would make me change my mind about my vote. I’m not voting personality. I’m voting policy. I don’t have to marry the man. I don’t have to deal with him. I have to deal with his policies. On abortion, [Harris] is not giving a gestational parameter of how late somebody can get an abortion. That cannot be-open ended. I was a NICU [neonatal intensive care unit] nurse for 17 years… I care about women’s rights. I care about women. The mother is the first patient. However, that is the turn-off to me that she won’t give an answer to that.” An Illinois Democrat, who voted for Joe Biden on the Democratic ticket in 2020, intends to vote for Harris on election day. “I am definitely concerned about the direction that reproductive rights are going in parts of the country. I feel that Trump’s attempts to communicate that he understands why [reproductive rights] is an important issue to women has fallen woefully short. I think Harris has an innate understanding of its importance, just being a woman and a woman of colour. Would I like her to lay out her plans a little bit more to potentially expand reproductive rights? Absolutely. But Trump has set the bar so low that she could really continue to not even mention it and she would still be doing a better job. [A Harris presidency] brings tears to my eyes just to think about. I have a nine-year-old daughter and she’s old enough to start having aspirations and to start paying attention to the world around her.” A library assistant, who voted for Trump in 2020, is currently undecided and contemplating “writing in” a candidate, meaning casting a vote for an individual not officially on the ballot. “This ain’t my first rodeo and I’ve gotten to the point in my life where I can look past the advertising they’re doing for two specific groups. It’s wonderful that we have Harris as a female seriously running for the presidency and that she has been a vice-president and has some experience. But Trump, when he was in office, I wasn’t too upset with what he was doing. I wouldn’t mind having a female president but some of Harris’s political doctrine and what I think is right don’t line up.” Angela, a graduate student in Iowa and a Democrat, supported Biden in the previous presidential election and intends to vote for Harris. “I really would love this to be a moment of celebration as we elect a woman of colour to our highest office, but unfortunately with how tight the election is against Trump and how disappointing [Harris’s] campaign has been on some of the issues that matter to me, it’s been hard to be as celebratory as I’d like.Obviously abortion is a huge issue that needs to be addressed, but I’m not necessarily happy, I should say, with either candidate’s approaches in addressing the issue. I understand Harris has a policy where she wants to codify Roe v Wade, but I think women’s rights and issues extend outside of just abortion access. Trump is very wishy-washy on the issue of women’s rights, so it’s hard to pin him down on any stance.” A retired Republican, who also supported the former president in 2020, plans to vote for Trump. “I think [Trump] is really the only possibility because I think Harris is just clueless and incompetent. I think she would be a disaster for this country, just listening to her mumble and evade. I just get a horrible feeling about her. I am pro-choice, actually, within reason. Not a late-term abortion. I don’t agree with that. But I think Trump by really relegating [legislation] to the states themselves, he’s being sensible. Harris doesn’t have much to run on so that’s her big selling point with women. She doesn’t have much substance to her, in other words, so she just hammers on and on about the abortion issue.” An independent voter, who cast a ballot for Biden in the 2020 presidential election, submitted a mail-in vote this year in support of Harris. “Reproductive rights for women are huge for me as a woman, especially living in the state of Florida where there is an amendment on the ballot that will guarantee the protection for abortion rights. I really want to support a party that’s going to support reproductive rights for women and not just women, but for everybody, because what’s to say it’s not going to spread elsewhere? It starts with women, usually, but it goes on and on.Our government is at least 50 years behind the times for a lot of things – especially other countries throughout the world having better representation. I have a niece that I love dearly. The fact that she could see [a female president], and just for that to be a normal thing for her, will be huge.” An independent voter from Georgia, identifying as a left-leaning moderate, will not support Harris or Trump this year due to her faith and anti-abortion stance. “I was actually going to vote for Harris, but then she started doubling down on how abortion is reproductive health… I’m a Catholic. I am pro-life.The problem that I ran into is that I don’t know how any Catholic can vote for somebody who spews the stuff like what we saw [from Trump] at Madison Square Garden recently. I take the injunction to welcome the stranger and to feed and clothe very seriously. So under those circumstances, I’ve got nobody I can vote for.” A retired resident of Texas, who voted for Biden in the previous presidential election, has cast an early vote for Harris. “I get so scared. We actually can’t go back. It’s very frightening to me. I had more rights than my granddaughter is going to have in her future and that’s not right. It is so disturbing that it is so close. [Trump] is a felon out on bail. I don’t understand the Republicans. They used to be the law and order [party], supposedly, and it’s now this. I think a lot [of women] are coming out and saying, ‘Why are you telling us what to do with our bodies?’ Abortion is a personal thing and it’s up to the doctor and the woman. It is none of my business.” As election day approaches, BBC Voter Voices is gathering insights from Americans nationwide regarding their key concerns. Are you an American voter? Want to join in? Apply to be featured in future BBC stories here. Do you live outside the US and have a question about the election? Tell us here or use the form below. Copyright 2024 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.